Dr. Michele Manos
  • Welcome
    • Privacy Policy
  • About Michele
    • Consulting Services
    • Contact
  • SoulCollageĀ®
    • The Casa 2026: Finding Balance
    • Online: All Hands on Deck
  • Edinburgh Festivals Forays

"Stage 4 Science Denial"

6/6/2014

 
Picture
It's a difficult time to be a scientist. We are increasingly underfunded and undervalued, and that's been hard to survive. Even worse, we are discredited and even demonized by politicians, the media, and a frighteningly misinformed and confused public. Science denial is truly at epidemic proportions, and the subsequent levels of ignorance are driving us further into this era of  irreversible self-destruction.

Today's politics can be extremel
y depressing, and lead to unhealthy levels of rage. I offer here my favorite antidotes from the past several weeks. Such brilliant satire is essential to my sanity.

On May 11, John Oliver did a delightful piece on HBO's Last Week Tonight. The video has gone viral, and should be required viewing for all Americans. The segment offered "A Statistically Representative Climate Change Debate" as a clever response to the disproportionate and misleading air time given to the "sides" of scientific information.

"You don't need people’s opinion on a fact," Oliver reminds us. "You might as well have a poll asking: ‘Which number is bigger, 15 or 5?’ or ‘Do owls exist?’ or ‘Are there hats?'"

In case you missed it, WATCH IT NOW:
Last Week Tonight (Climate Change Debate)


Of course, Jon Stewart's The Daily Show is the mother (father?) of such intelligent satire, and where John Oliver apprenticed. They've also kept hammering on the anti-science crisis, particularly as embarrassing inaccuracies flow from the mouths of lawmakers and pundits on the extreme right. But recently, they gave the anti-science left some well-earned ridicule.  On June 2, in response to the recent measles outbreaks in the US, The Daily Show's Samantha Bee investigated the epidemic of vaccine-science denial. It's a great one to watch.

We are introduced to blogger Sarah Pope, author of the Healthy Home Economist (and vaccine effectiveness denier). She is not a scientist or a clinician. Her website informs us that she does hold a degree "from the University of Pennsylvania, an Ivy League institution." She explains to Samantha Bee, "There is no herd immunity.....that's a myth." Pope also rebukes the concept of scientific consensus. Bee confidently diagnoses Pope with "stage 4 science denial" and defines her as the index case of the anti-vaccine outbreak in the US.

Dr. Paul Offit, renowned vaccine expert and science myth debunker, suggests that such denial will not be curbed until we have some large and dramatic vaccine-preventable disease outbreaks in the US.

Samantha Bee concludes, "Once Florida's under water and we all have polio, it'll be better."


HAVE A LOOK:

The Daily Show (Outbreak of Liberal Idiocy)

(Yes, it's particularly entertaining to me, as a scientist who's been focused on infectious diseases. I cherish any humor I can have so close to "home.")


Comments are closed.

    Politics Writ Large
    "Politics is public health in its most profound sense."
    Adapted from Virchow. 

    Archives

    February 2018
    January 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    June 2017
    March 2017
    November 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
Photo from Tekniska museet