Dr. Michele Manos
  • Welcome
    • Privacy Policy
  • About Michele
    • Contact
  • SoulCollage®
    • Upcoming Retreats >
      • SoulCollage as Symphony, Marin County
      • Scottsdale Retreat: Communing at The Casa
    • Together Tuesdays
    • Listening to Your Cards in New Ways
    • Bringing Creativity and Confidence to Workshops
    • Card Talk (A SoulCollager's Musings)
  • Public Health Consulting

Learning the Bagpipes (and other reasons to look toward Scotland)

9/19/2014

 
Picture
Rule Britannia……Scotland never, never, never shall be slaves.

That’s my concise summary of how Scotland’s referendum for independence played out on September 18.  While Scottish National Party leader, Alex Salmond conceded defeat, he celebrated that British politics will be unable “to go back to business as usual.” Indeed, with a solid 45% of Scots voting for independence, London must respond by providing Scotland greater autonomy and more attention to its distinct needs and values.

My fascination with Scotland precedes this historic vote. I fell in love with the place and the people when I first visited decades ago. I am not alone in this. I’ve rarely heard anyone say anything less adoring than “I love Scotland” and “I love the Scottish people” after returning from there.  This is remarkable since many visitors are greeted by rain (or snow) every day; there are weeks of summer without sunshine. But the stark highland scenery and charming roadside pubs are delightful in any weather. And Edinburgh’s fabulous summer events, particularly the Festival Fringe and the International Book Festival have not only captured many hearts, they are gold-standard models for similar events throughout the world. There’s something magical there, beyond a model democracy.

In the past weeks, it seemed that many other outsiders also cared deeply for Scotland. Opinions on the referendum flowed in from across the world. Top economists warned that current British and European economic conditions made independence a disastrous move for Scotland’s economy. Most convincing for me was Paul Krugman’s September 7 column, titled as if to address a good friend – “Scots, What the Heck?” And while pro-independence activists framed such opinions as scaremongering, I’d like to believe they came from a blend of tough love and undying respect for Scotland and its people.

And since voting on the referendum, Scotland deserves our respect even more. Their voter turnout of over 86% was hailed by the British press as “astonishing” and “incredible.”  That’s one of the highest voting rates in the democratic world, in any election or any referendum. Some areas reported turnouts of over 90%. Over 3.6 million Scots came out to participate in their democracy and shape their future.

Looking homeward, only about 60% of the voting eligible population in the US votes in presidential year elections, and about 40% participate in midterm elections. In Arizona, the numbers are even lower: in the 2010 presidential election just 53% of the eligible population voted. Arizona’s voter turnout is consistently below the national average. How sad that so many of our citizens are unwilling or unable to embrace the power of the vote.

We can learn much from Scotland. Although they didn’t make it to independence with their votes, they solidified the inevitably of change. Despite losing the referendum, those 1.6 million who voted YES for independence secured a new future for themselves and future generations of Scots. Voting isn’t always about winning. Sometimes it’s just about the opportunity to be counted.

Want to see some changes in your political landscape? Don’t complain. Vote.

Armed militias now chasing scientists - what next?

9/3/2014

 
Picture
This photo borrowed from VICE.
(A version of this piece was published in the Green Valley News)

When a headline reads “Scientists run into militiamen,” you’ve got to wonder whether it can get much crazier in these borderlands we call home. Those wildlife researchers had many concerns on August 23 as they returned to their campsite from Onyx Cave in the nearby Santa Rita Mountains: potential rabies exposure from the bats they were studying, rattlesnakes enjoying the cool summer night, pumas looking for dinner. But, I’m certain they never expected to be terrorized by heavily armed militiamen. Science denial makes things hard enough for scientists these days, but now field researchers must also fear militias. As dedicated professionals tackle urgent issues in the borderlands like deadly mosquito-borne diseases or the loss of species that are crucial to agriculture, who will be protecting them?

The greatest danger for anyone working or recreating in our local wilderness areas may now be these untrained, unauthorized defenders of the border. Unlike most immigrants, traffickers, and drug mules who prefer to remain unseen, these thugs seek out the thrill of confrontation and opportunities to engage in combat. The dangers posed by these rogue militias clearly earn them the title of “illegals” on our border.

Militia activity has surged recently, and Arizona is a destination for visitors keen to take border security into their own hands. As reported by Nogales International, a militia group from Pennsylvania (apparently it’s no fun defending the shores of Lake Erie) arrived here this summer, advised by leader Mark Kessler to bring armor, helmets, weapons and ammunition. Kessler also promised engagement with “heavily armed cartel escorts trucking dope into Arizona.” And what made our state such an attraction? Other than the delusion that one could survive an actual cartel confrontation, perhaps it’s that Arizona almost became the only state to implement a volunteer militia to patrol the border.

Let’s not forget that in 2012, Arizona’s Republican governor and lawmakers forged a high profile attempt to create a border militia. Their bill (SB 1083, which failed in the State House) appropriated almost 2 million dollars for the Arizona Special Missions Unit, a group of armed, minimally trained volunteers charged with patrolling the border with Mexico, confiscating property, and arresting and detaining individuals. Under the direction of the governor and her appointed commander, militia members were to be granted the same immunity protections as public law enforcement.  Members were to be paid for training and drills. Employers were to grant paid leaves of absence for militia activities. This was that same extremist approach to legislation that continues to humiliate Arizona not only in the spotlight of political satire, but in the mainstream press.

The poor judgment of Arizona’s Republican politicians has made our borderlands a welcoming ground for armed militias. Such dangerous folly must come to an end. On November 4, let’s elect candidates that will care for the public through informed reasoning, not militant absurdity.

Michele herself has tracked wildlife in the dark of night, and on multiple occasions returned to her car by flashlight after exploring Onyx Cave. She now fears the militias when exploring the wilderness near her home.

    Politics Writ Large
    "Politics is public health in its most profound sense."
    Adapted from Virchow. 

    Archives

    February 2018
    January 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    June 2017
    March 2017
    November 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
Photo used under Creative Commons from Tekniska museet